The Evans at Canal Shores Review | In the Loop Chicago Golf
The recently renovated Canal Shores is a perfect fit in the Chicago golf scene. Think Draymond Green on the 2015 Warriors. Those Warriors teams needed someone to play hard-nosed defense while not clogging the lane on offense; they needed a center who could pass and play the pick-and-roll game with Steph. Draymond might have been a role player if he was drafted by many other franchises, but he wasn’t; he’s a four-time NBA champion and former Defensive Player of the Year. Maybe that last point would make me a casual, but my point stands: Draymond was a perfect fit on those Warriors teams.
Chicago golf has its Stephen Curry and Klay Thompsons in the elite private clubs like Chicago and Shoreacres (both recently named in Golf.com’s Top 100 Courses in the World). Chicago also has its Andre Iguodala and Harrison Barnes—starters with an undeniable impact—in its great public golf like Cog Hill, Harborside, and Thunderhawk. The city has its Festus Ezeli and Mo Speights role players in the Park District courses Sydney Marovitz and Jackson Park. Festus Ezeli and Mo Speights did not play 37 minutes per game in the 2015 Finals like Draymond did. Why is that? Because they didn’t have the right skill set.
Canal Shores is everything a city parks course should be: an easy walk for all ages, a great short-game practice area, and—most important—playable but intriguing for all skill levels. The highlight of the course is the greens. Each of the greens has contouring—at times severe contouring—which impacts the strategy around how a player approaches shots, chips, and putts. On a day when the greens are rolling, there are some diabolical pin positions where being on the wrong side of the hole can lead to easy three-putts even from short distances.
A number of holes resemble Template Golf Holes, labeled and made popular in America by the great C.B. Macdonald in the early 1900s. Template Golf Holes are modeled after or borrow concepts such as green shape, hazard placement, or contours from famous golf holes in Scotland and Ireland. To name a few: the par-3 6th has a punchbowl green; the par-3 8th resembles a Redan without bunkers; and the par-3 11th is a Biarritz.
The standout of these is the Biarritz. It plays a bit short to be a traditional Biarritz and does not have the traditional bunkering, but the template is unmistakable, with the green having two distinct landing areas and a deep depression splitting them. Canal’s version of the Biarritz is a great example of a hole that creates intrigue for players of all levels:
For beginners who have not seen variety in golf courses, the severity of the depression can have a wow factor, creating an intimidating but thrilling obstacle to navigate. Putting or chipping around it can be challenging, but the hole allows for run-up shots since there are no hazards between the tees and the green. Not easy, but they shouldn’t lose a golf ball (unless they pull-hook one to the left).
For mid-level handicaps, the green often puts pressure on their second shot. If the player hits the green on the wrong plateau or in the depression, they’re left with a challenging lag putt which can easily result in a three-putt. Missing the green means the second shot—chip or putt—must not miss the plateau that holds the pin; otherwise par is out of the question. If they do hit the right plateau, they are rewarded with a stress-free par and a birdie look.
For players closer to scratch, each hole at Canal Shores will be a birdie opportunity from the tee. The 11th Biarritz puts a bit more pressure on these players to hit a more exacting iron shot to earn that birdie opportunity.
This is a straightforward case study in how contours can add intrigue to otherwise mundane landscapes for all players by not overly punishing bad shots but also rewarding good ones. This is what Canal Shores does best at many points in its short 18 holes.
The other major skill Canal Shores brings to Chicago golf is its putting green, which is large enough to double as a putting course. Large enough to give space for 10+ players to practice at once, the expansive practice green is defined by large swales and mounds which create natural separations for practice areas. The contours also provide the opportunity to create wild, sweeping putts by cutting across or going over them. These are the types of putts you don’t often see in Chicago public golf, but they would be good to practice before taking on a place like Sand Valley or some of the private Golden Age clubs. Interesting practice areas are hard to find in public golf in Chicago, so this is another standout feature for Canal.
Canal Shores does have some shortcomings as a short course, though. To start, the ground most of the course sits on is hardpan clay, and farther away from the fairways, rocks can be found in the soil, leading to the occasional dinged club (they’re meant to ding eventually; a couple marks aren’t worth stressing over). The repeated par-threes can also feel redundant from the tee, but this is minimized by the variety in length and green shape.
Canal Shores cannot be compared with other full-length regulation courses; it’s not meant to be one. It’s not meant to be Stephen Curry or Andre Iguodala. It also really cannot be compared to courses outside of the city, as the suburbs do not have the same needs. It just wouldn’t work as well in the 2015 Cavs’ offense. It has a defined role as an interesting but accessible course for Chicago’s public to enjoy practicing or learning how to play golf. It fills this role far better than some of its direct competitors in Edgebrook or Sydney Marovitz. Which brings me to my point: in Game 7 of the NBA Finals, who would you rather start—Festus Ezeli or Draymond Green?