Sheep Ranch Course Review - Bandon Dunes | In the Loop Chicago Golf
History of the Sheep Ranch
Mike Keiser and the Dream Golf team started as rule breakers but since have been anointed as the trend-setters of American golf resort philosophy. Sheep Ranch is an extension of that rule-breaking approach, maybe by necessity, that provides a great template for what a second or third course at a golf resort should look like. Don’t get it wrong Sheep Ranch is not a second rate course, there are many reasons why this could be someone’s favorite course at Bandon and more as to why it might be the most fun.
Quick history on Sheep Ranch for those who haven’t heard the lore (an appropriate word here). Sheep ranch started when Mike Keiser and business partner /friend Phil Friedman acquired property north of the original three resort courses with the goal of expansion (Bandon, Pacific, and Trails). Tom Doak was commissioned to design 13 greens which could be played from a number of different tees in any order. The set-up provided a highly unique golfing experience where groups could play a unique combination of holes each loop, like a pick our own adventure. The design made for great matches where winner of the last hole picks the next hole. This semi-private course had an unofficial tee time process, was not officially linked to the Bandon Resort, and could only be played by two groups a day. Initial curiosity of the mysterious Sheep Ranch from golf writers and Bandon Resort guests was so overwhelming, that for a time, Bandon employees were even asked to stop answering questions related to the property. Finally around 2018, Keiser convinced Friedman to add Sheep Ranch into the resort fold. Coore and Crenshaw were selected to redesign the original layout since Doak already had two courses at Bandon: Pacific Dunes and Old MacDonald. Sheep Ranch was officially opened to the public in 2020.
Key Elements of the Course Design
Its no surprise the team of Coore and Crenshaw delivered a thoughtful, perfect fit for the five mile point. The defining feature of the property, unencumbered close-up views of the Pacific Ocean, provided Coore and Crenshaw with two factors to guide their design: opportunities for thrilling shots along the coastline and unimpeded coastal winds. A good golf course architect will let the property guide the design. The wind and coastline are so clearly the driving factors in the design of Sheep Ranch, the course has a simple elegance.
There is beauty in variety when it comes to course design. Sheep Ranch delivers variety in how players see and play shots along the coastline, a few examples:
- Hitting an approach shot on the short Par 5 1st hole directly towards the ocean
- Cutting the corner of a cliff with the tee shot of the long par 4 6th hole
- Hitting driver north on a reachable par 4 16th with the coastline bordering the left side of the fairway
- Playing the par 3 7th south with the coastline bordering the right and backside of the green
The coastline plays into the strategy of many holes playing as the hazard for heroic carries, the backdrop on approach shots to mess with depth-perception, and a natural border for other holes. If Sheep Ranch is the most fun course at Bandon, the shots along the coastline primary reason not to mention the spectacular views of the Pacific.
Now to the other more menacing factor, the wind. When at Sheep Ranch to say you’re exposed to the wind is an understatement. If there is even a moderate coastal wind it will impact every shot you play during the round from adding 30+ yards to an iron shot, to pushing you off balance on a putt. During a round golfers will interact with the wind in many ways. The routing weaves its way to and from the clubhouse so golfers are will be playing into and with the wind at many different points. Bandon traditionally experiences wind from the North in the summer and from the South in the winter, so playing at different times of year can provide dramatic variety in playing experiences on many holes. Again there is beauty in variety. Considering the wind can be brutal for play and maintenance, the course was designed with only grass bunkers, something generally only featured on municipal courses without the funding. It also features some extremely wide fairways so there aren’t many lost balls off the tee. The result is a course which can play the easiest on property with many birdie opportunities on a blue bird day (no rain, no wind), but can also be a grinding test to keep composure under the elements when the wind is high. Variety.
Stand-out Holes
While its not most players favorite course, Sheep Ranch has a number of holes which could be:
Best Opening Hole at Bandon: Playing the first hole at Sheep Ranch gives the feeling of walking out of the tunnel into an historic college football stadium. A handful of trees and underlying gorse limit views of the course and ocean from the tee; it also narrows the fairway from both sides into a “Gate” which players must hit their tee shot through. After teeing off players make the walk through the “tunnel”, pass through the “gate”, and are presented with a beautiful golf hole headed directly towards the ocean. On an eerie foggy morning this walk feels like a spiritual experience. As the first round of a trip, the first hole at Sheep Ranch truly gives you that “welcome to the game” feeling.
A Stunning Dual-Green (Par 3 3rd and 17th): This might be the coolest green concept at Bandon. It’s an expansive dual-green which plays as two distinct tiers separated by rolling terraces of green. As documented in Nature of the Game by Stephen Goodwin, the crew member who shaped the green during construction modeled the rolling design after the crashing waves of the Pacific Ocean. The green by itself is remarkable but sitting alongside its inspiration, the Pacific Ocean, makes it unforgettable. The two holes which share the green play different. The third hole is a short par three which presents a moderate opening to the expansive green. Depending on the pin it can be a semi-blind shot that requires trust in the swing and management of the wind to avoid the gorse. Once on the putting surface players get their second great view of the ocean during the round and a look down to the conjoined 17th green below. There are little humps or mounds which, along with the ocean, will dictate the breaks of putts. Local Caddies will argue not all putts break towards the ocean.
The seventeenth hole is another short par three with plays with the ocean directly on the left. The majority of this tier is visible from the tee but most players will be more focused on the ocean views. This is a great example of a risk/reward par three where wind will play a major factor. Players must decide how close they want to get to the coastline for a birdie opportunity, especially when the pin is placed closer to the edge. Themes of the course perfectly shown in one hole: thrilling shots along the coast with the wind playing a big factor. While playing the seventeenth you can see crashing waves looking towards the ocean or the third green, another spiritual experience.
A Credit Card Bill (Par 4 6th Hole): In a No Laying Up video about golf courses in Grand Rapids, a golf hole was described as a credit card hole; you have to pay the bill at some point and if you wait interest will start to accrue. Its a great metaphor for golf holes with a concept of delayed risk and is illustrated on the 6th at Sheep Ranch. The hole is a dogleg right where the tee shot cuts over the ocean cliff and the rest of the hole runs alongside the coastline. The bill players must pay is getting close to the ocean on one shot. Off-the-tee a player needs to decide how much of the cliff they want cover especially when a miss right will oftentimes end up down the cliff. There is ample room to bailout left but that is just pushing off the credit card balance for a later shot. The approach shot plays along a straight fairway towards a moderately sized green with a grass bunker on the left and the ocean bordering the right. A middle or right pin forces a shot which, if pushed, can end up down the cliff. Similar to the tee shot there is ample room to bail out left. A smart player will consider their strengths and consciously take more risk on one shot, to make the other easier. This is the path to par or birdie. The player who bails out left on the first two shots will face a wedge shot to the narrow side of the green with the ocean directly behind. For a player too scared to take on the first two shots this can be a daunting task. Interest has accrued and the bill has gotten bigger. A great example of a strategic hole which forces players to take on risk for a decent score.

Closing Thoughts
In summary, Sheep Ranch uses the properties best features to create playing experiences other places can’t. It has some of best holes on property which can highly vary in difficulty from day to day due to weather conditions. It also ignored once common rules for designing American resort courses in both its first and second iterations. The simple elegance of Coore and Crenshaw’s design only needs a simple statement to sum up the playing experience: Sheep Ranch is fun.